Saturday, May 2, 2015

Fearfully trying times from which we have learned little


W

orld War One was a fearfully trying time.

Interestingly, the pacifists among us are finding the four year-long recognition of that disturbing and pointless societal conflict equally trying, but for different and yet similarly damning reasons.

World War One was meant to be the war
that ended all wars - that was most
certainly the case for millions of people,
but not the world, rather it was just
the beginning of damnable fearful times.
Not for a second is the commitment and bravery of those involved in that war questioned, but it seems fatefully futile that thousands of young Australians travelled to places they had never heard of and died in droves.

Long has our desire to fight and the causes of war troubled me and almost without exception the initial disputation that escalated to become war, bringing death a destruction of unimagined extremes, can be traced to the intellectual and emotional immaturity of just a few people.

Subsequently, most any philosophical thoughts about war and its causes interest me and these notes by U.S. scientist and author, Peter Turchin, caught my eye. He said: “This is not to argue that wars are good. I hope that the humanity will eventually evolve to the point where we can abolish wars and all the misery they cause. But when we do it, we will still need an engine of creative destruction to prevent runaway accumulation of power and wealth by the few, and to weed out dysfunctional societies that lost their ability to cooperate.”

Much can be read into Turchin’s observations, but it is the final observation - dysfunctional societies that lost their ability to cooperate – which was bad enough 100 years ago, but is now even worse as democracies are now becoming oligarchies in which inequality prevails and societal dysfunction is afoot.

Some see Shiva as the God of destruction whose task is to clear away the old to make room for the new.

One commentator says, “The present culture of war does neither. Rather is maintains a paradigm of continual struggle for control amongst the power elite that leaves in its wake nothing but death and destruction.

“The so-called value of war as an expression of creative destruction is to ignore the pain of the mother who, standing among the rubble of her former home, holding the lifeless body of her youngest child in her arms, the disillusionment of the soldier who returns to an empty future, crippled in mind or body.”

‘War, what is it good for? Absolutely nothing!” he writes, quoting the song.

So considering that, it is time we stopped remembering, recognizing and celebrating what was, and spending untold millions of dollars building myths from events we should never have been a part of and turned our gaze toward today, tomorrow and to our children’s, their children’s future without war..

It has been our addiction to growth, answered through our exploitation of fossil fuels that has enriched the world’s elites, worsened inequality and entrenched societal dysfunction making war a constant recurrence.